What do I want for my children? Most parents, when asked that question, would say “for them to be happy”. It’s an understandable response, but I can’t help feeling it’s a wee bit spurious. The world is home to many people who are made happy by inflicting misery on others. One man’s mirth is another’s woe. Better, perhaps, to encourage our offspring to do the right thing, and see joy as a wonderful by-product, rather than the sole objective of a life well lived.

I’ve been moseying through this moral maze in the days after my eldest daughter’s A-level results. Edith got the grades she needed to study geology. There will be a hefty student loan. But because she’s chosen a vocational degree that often leads to a well-paid job, she might be in a position to get a foothold on the housing ladder and start a family before indebtedness stops her biological clock. Sadly, some of her friends may be denied that choice.

My wife and I, both graduates, no longer incline to the view that fulfilment and higher education are synonymous. We all know graduates whose minds do not appear to have been stretched by a bracing dose of higher education. Many end up in call centres or shops. A consensus seems to be building that, as a society, we are sending too many young people to university. They have a hoot for three years, but the hangover lasts a lifetime.

As I believe that having children is the single most educative action available to an individual, I hope mine recognise that, when it comes to university, there is a difference between short-term happiness and long-term fulfilment. My five daughters are part of a cohort whose reproductive window is unprecedentedly narrow. By the time they have got a job that pays down student debt and allows them to save for a mortgage, their fertility may be in free fall.

Of course, this is not to view parenthood as the be-all and end-all. Nor is it to place expectations on my girls that I would not place on my boy. It’s just that he can reasonably expect to have children into his 50s. His sisters can’t.


​How to continue reading…

This article appears in the Catholic Herald magazine - to read it in full subscribe to our digital edition from just 30p a week

The Catholic Herald is your essential weekly guide to the Catholic world; latest news, incisive opinion, expert analysis and spiritual reflection