The Will of the People

by Albert Weale, Polity Press, 121pp, £9.99

“This book was written in a hurry” are the opening lines here; they hardly inspire confidence. When the preface then refers entirely, and in negative terms, to Brexit, railing against anti-parliamentarian populism and the Daily Mail, the heart sinks even further. Do we really need more invective against “stupid, racist” Brexiteers?

The reader need not worry. The Will of the People is a calm, lucid and only sometimes irritating discourse, ultimately calling for a second referendum, on account of “the will of the people” not actually existing. On the surface, this is obviously true. Forty-eight per cent of British voters opted to stay in the EU. Weale, a professor of political theory at University College London, reminds us that not since 1935 has the UK returned to government a party with more than 50 per cent of the vote.

The “will of the people” is also hard to define, owing to time and space. If the polls are correct, the majority of Britons would vote to stay in the European Union if asked again. Thus the will of the people is forever unstable and impossible to pin down. It also depends on your perspective. Two years ago, was someone in Edinburgh living in a country where the will of the people was to leave the EU? It depends whether you regard him as living in the United Kingdom or in Scotland.

It’s true that “the will of the people” is nonsense. But Weale is being too literal-minded. The phrase is obviously used figuratively to mean “the majority of the people”.

​How to continue reading…

This article appears in the Catholic Herald magazine - to read it in full subscribe to our digital edition from just 30p a week

The Catholic Herald is your essential weekly guide to the Catholic world; latest news, incisive opinion, expert analysis and spiritual reflection